He Figured It Out Four Years Late
I haven’t been able to stop thinking about the Lindsay Clancy trial.
It’s in its second week in Massachusetts, and like a lot of people who work in perinatal mental health, I’ve been following it closely and finding it hard to distance myself. It doesn’t help that every perinatal group I’m in processes the testimony daily. Three children are dead. That’s the fact, and nothing I write here is an argument about what she’s responsible for or a request that anyone ignore that fact.
You can hold two truths at once. In the work I do we call this a dialectic, two things that look like opposites, both carrying a kernel of truth, and neither one canceling out the other.
You already know how this works even if you’ve never used that word for it. You love your kids more than anything, and some nights you are counting the minutes until bedtime. Both are true. Acknowledging the second one doesn’t make the first one less real, and you don’t have to pick.
Here’s the harder version. A person can be accountable for what she did, and the system around her can have failed at nearly every point where something might have been caught. The reality of the second point doesn’t take anything away from the first.
What I keep noticing is that almost nobody is talking about the other parent. I don’t mean him specifically. I mean fathers, and how they fit into all this. Lindsay’s ex-husband testified for days about what he watched happen to her over those months. The anxiety that kept building. The insomnia. One medication after another. He was in continuous contact with a mother who was deteriorating; more than any prescriber or OB or therapist ever could be.
And in all those months, nobody ever asked him what he was seeing. Or if they did, it was so brief and superficial it didn’t register for him.
I want to be careful here, because this is not really a story about one family. It’s a story about how we built perinatal care, and it’s true in almost every family I work with.
Here’s what I actually see in my practice.
Most fathers never come in. That’s the first thing, and I think it shapes the treatment significantly. Mom books the intake, mom comes alone, and honestly I have no reliable way of knowing what makes it home from that session. How much gets passed along. In what form. Whether it lands at all. I’m working with half a family system and hoping the other half hears about it secondhand.
Some dads do find us. They call on her behalf, or they’re the reason she finally made the appointment. Those men already know something is wrong and that more support is needed, and that awareness is often huge is the speed of recovery and wellbeing.
When men do come in as part of a couple, what I usually see is defensiveness, or minimizing. I don’t think it’s because they don’t care. I think being asked to look at their own part in this means admitting they’re struggling, right at the moment when they feel their whole job is to be the steady one. So the conversation stays on mom, where it feels safer. A father will answer forty detailed questions about his wife’s sleep and then go quiet when I ask about his own.
And here’s the thing I most want you to hear. The fathers I’ve worked with usually recognized their own anxiety or depression looking backward. Not during the newborn months. Later, when the baby is two, or four, and something starts showing up in the family, and someone finally puts words to what’s been going on for years. *They can see it clearly in hindsight. *They just couldn’t see it from inside it, and there was nobody outside helping them recognize their own pain and distress.
That’s a delay measured in years, and we’ve all just accepted it.
Notice where dad is through all of this. He was at the prenatal visits. He was in the delivery room. He is not in the room where any of it could actually get addressed. The part of the system that has him never asks, and the part that could help him he never walks into.
Some numbers, and they’re worse than most people expect.
Perinatal depression in fathers runs around 10% on its own. When the mother is going through a perinatal mood or anxiety disorder, the rate in partners climbs to somewhere between 24 and 50%. So in the homes where mom is in crisis, up to half of partners are struggling too. And we don’t screen a single one of them, not at the OB, not at the pediatrician, not anywhere.
Part of why we miss it is that we’re watching for the wrong thing. Depression in fathers often doesn’t look like sadness. It looks like a short fuse. Working later than he needs to. Disappearing into his phone on the couch. Aches and stomach problems with no clear cause. Drinking a little more than he used to. A kind of going-quiet that everyone reads as “he’s just tired.” He doesn’t look depressed to anyone, including himself, because the picture in his head of depression is crying, and he isn’t crying.
Underneath that sits something almost every American father has absorbed from unspoken cultural messages: his job is to be the strong one. Keep the income steady. Pay the bills. Keep the routines going. Handle the logistics so she can heal. And being the strong one somehow gets defined as not needing anything, so the worse he feels the less likely he is to mention it, because saying it feels like adding weight to her load.
Now put that in a real house.
Not a first baby in a quiet apartment. A four-year-old in the middle of toilet training with accidents at 2 a.m., a toddler having night terrors, a newborn up every ninety minutes, a kindergarten transition that isn’t going well, everybody sick in February.
Mom is struggling, and the whole family’s regulation and routines organizes around her wellbeing. Who does bedtime. Who holds it together and keeps the whole family moving. What everyone stops expecting. Nobody sleeps more than three hours in a row for months.
Dad isn’t thinking clearly, because nobody thinks clearly like that. He’s just getting through the day, and he isn’t thinking much past the next day. Understandable.
Here’s something essential to understand: it is nearly impossible to assess your partner’s mental health when you’re drowning yourself.
When you’re that depleted, everything looks like exhaustion. Her going quiet looks like tired. Her irritability looks like tired. Your own numbness looks like tired. You lose the baseline you’d need to notice anything had changed, because you can’t remember what normal was. And you’re so far into survival mode that stopping to examine any of it feels like a luxury you don’t have time for.
So you end up with two people underwater, each one assuming the other is the stable one, each protecting the other from what they’re carrying, both waiting for someone else to say it first.
That isn’t a communication problem between two people who love each other. It’s what happens when two parents have to carry everything alone, with no consistent support or breaks.
What to do about it
There are three questions we rarely ask partners. Ask all three, and ask each one about both of you.
Do you know what you’re looking for? In your partner, and in yourself. In mothers this can show up as rage, or rigidity, or intrusive thoughts she’s too ashamed to say out loud, or an inability to sleep even when the baby finally does. Constant worrying for the baby’s health. Disconnecting from things she enjoyed, friends, or even family. In fathers it usually shows up as irritability, pulling away, overworking, escaping into hobbies, or numbness. Gaming late into the night. Staying longer at work than really necessary. Drinking more than usual. Neither parent shows the sadness people expect.
Do you know what to do when you see it? Knowing something is wrong and knowing what to do about it are two different things. Who to call. What’s urgent and what can wait until Monday. How to bring it up with your partner so it doesn’t land as an accusation. Where a father goes when it’s him that needs support, which almost nobody can answer, because we’ve never told him he was allowed to be the patient.
How are you actually doing? This isn’t a courtesy question. How you’re doing is what you’re using to read everything else in your house. When you’re that far gone, you can’t read any of it accurately, including whether the person you love is in trouble. Take some time to actually connect with yourself and reflect on what you need. Its ok not be ok.
One thing this week.
Ten minutes tonight. Ask that third question about yourself first, then about your partner. Not “we’re getting through it.” The real answer. How are you really feeling, and what do you really need.
You go first. That isn’t a slogan, it’s the order of operations. You can’t read anyone else accurately until you’ve been honest about where you are.
If your honest answer is I’m not okay, I want to say to you what I’ve said to a lot of parents sitting in my office. You didn’t miss this because you weren’t trying hard enough. You missed it because nobody told you what to look for, and because you were overwhelmed at the time. Nobody handed you a map for this. You’re here now, and help is available.
Then bring it to whoever is treating either of you. “Here’s what I’ve noticed over the last three weeks” is one of the most useful things a provider can hear. We would love to understand your perspective, and to help.
And if you’re the dad reading this, one thing directly to you. You are not the support staff here. You’re a parent in the perinatal period, with your own risk, your own symptoms, and your own claim to care. Nobody has told you that, because our system was never built to say it.
And if you’re a provider reading this (an OB, a midwife, a pediatrician, a therapist) here’s the one thing I’d ask of you. At the postpartum visit, at the six-week check, at the well-child visits through the first year, the partner is very often standing right there in the room. Turn to dad (or non-birthing partner) and ask one question. How is he sleeping. How is he doing. It takes twenty seconds, and you may be the only person in that family’s life who is positioned to ask it at all. You don’t need a protocol or a billing code to turn your head and show legitimate concern.
And I should say something about my own practice here, because it would be easy to write all of this as though we have it figured out.
We don’t. We take mom as the patient. She’s who calls, she’s who books, she’s who we assess. We don’t insist her partner participate. We have no mechanism for making sure he’s been assessed himself, or that anyone anywhere is supporting him. If he comes in, we’re glad to see him and we’ll treat him as a patient in his own right. But we aren’t going out and getting him, and I know those aren’t the same thing.
It’s a genuinely hard problem to solve. He isn’t my patient. He hasn’t asked me for anything. There’s no part of the visit structure that creates an opening. But hard and unimportant are different, and this one matters enough that we should be working on it. I’m saying that out loud partly so that I have to.
Here’s what gives me hope about this particular problem. Fixing it doesn’t take a new profession, or new funding, or a law. It takes including a person who is already deeply involved, and deeply invested.
Partners belong in the care plan from the first prenatal visit forward. Not as the person who drove her to the appointment. As part of the family we’re treating.
That means dad gets the same education she gets about what perinatal mood and anxiety disorders actually look like, in her and in himself. It means somebody asks him how he’s doing, at least once, and writes down what he says. It means he’s part of the discharge conversation, and the six-week visit, and the well-child checks he’s already attending. And it means there is somewhere for him to go when the answer isn’t good.
None of that is expensive and none of it is complicated. Every piece of it is something we already do for mothers, extended to the person sitting beside her.
We’ve had the research for more than a decade. What we’ve never had is the decision. That’s the entire gap, and it’s the kind that closes the moment enough of us stop treating it as acceptable.
**If you’re in Texas and either of you needs support, we treat fathers and partners at CPFH, not as an add-on to someone else’s care, as patients. New patients within 5 to 7 days, urgent cases within 48 hours. ***cpfh.org
And if you’re a provider with a father you’re worried about, send him. Same timeline. You don’t have to wait until mom is our patient.*
Originally published in Raising Resilient Families, Dr. Lauren Pasqua’s LinkedIn newsletter, on August 13, 2026.